Archive for

Capitalism Nature Socialism

The international socialist journal Capitalism Nature Socialism has featured arguments for a money-free future. In the previous ten issues, the following have appeared:

Andreas Exner (2014) 'Degrowth and Demonetization: On the Limits of a Non-Capitalist Market Economy', Capitalism Nature Socialism, 25:3, 9–27.

David Barkin (2014) 'Life Without Money' [book review] Capitalism Nature Socialism, 25:2, 126–128

Ariel Salleh (2014),Ariel Salleh (2014) 'A Vernacular Response to Barkin's Review of Life Without Money', Capitalism Nature Socialism, 25:2, 128–131.

For more by Andreas Exner, see: Demonetize it!

Contesting capitalism and Leo Panitch

In the 7th Annual Wheelwright Lecture, delivered in Sydney in September 2014, Leo Panitch let forth against the likes of David Harvey and Wolfgang Streek — including many in the audience. I respond here, which is the prose version that inspired the poem at the same site (see last post):

Be a flower!

Political poem on the Progress in Political Economy site

The first poem to appear on the University of Sydney's great Progress in Political Economy site advocates a life beyond money and the state:

Gift economies/networks on the ground

Over the last two weeks I've talked with some key people in a couple of groups pursuing gift networks and collective sufficiency without money on the ground:
1. Patrick Jones and Meg Ulman, who live in the rural town of Daylesford (Central Victoria), have been active in a series of sustainability activities locally.

They've just returned from a fifteen month tour of Australia checking out on what other communities are up to, too.

Read more of their adventures at home and interstate here:

2. Another group — whose members are active in our Melbourne ecosocialism discussion group — is urban. They include Theo Kitchener, who wrote about the Doing It Ourselves network's early ideas in an article that appears as a pdf that can be downloaded here:

They are experimenting with developing a series of cooperatives that try to do as much as they can with as little money as possible.

3. Gift economy advocate Terry Leahy will be in Melbourne to speak at a New International Book Shop arranged event at the Victorian Trades Hall Council on the night of Friday 13 March. He will show the documentary film that his sister Gillian Leahy and he made on an African village that became collectively sufficient by applying permaculture methods, amongst other techniques.

You can find out some more on The Chikukwa Project and on Terry's work more broadly here.

Melbourne & Castlemaine (Australia) Trade School

We want a Trade School for Melbourne & Castlemaine. We’re looking for Melbournians and Castlemaniacs to help set up and maintain this Trade School — to barter skills and knowledge — and seeking the contact details for those wanting to use it once we are set up.

Trade Schools exist worldwide and started in NYC in 2010. People teach anything others will barter items or jobs to learn, such as: pilates, drawing, photography, cookery, games (Scrabble/chess/Sudoku), weaving, political/literary theory, fixing bikes, restoring furniture, book binding, gardening, detoxing, music making, singing, writing, knitting, making musical instruments, cleaning, languages, yarn bombing, speaking, facilitating, bee-keeping, IT skills, dancing, carpentary, cappaccino-making, basket-making, painting, pottery, poetry…

Trade School is an alternative, self-organised school running on barter and works like this:
1)Teachers propose classes and ask for items/jobs from students, e.g. you teach butter making and ask students to bring heavy cream, jars, bread, music tips, clothes, vegetables, or help find you an apartment.
2) As students sign up they agree to bring an item or do a job for a teacher.
Trade School is for those of us who value hands-on knowledge, mutual respect and the social nature of exchange. Everyone can offer something.
Source: Adapted from Trade School NYC site

To find out more on this non-monetary style exchange model, advice for starters and all the various Trade Schools around the world, see:


The Pacific Network on Globalisation (PANG) features a document to all the members of the World Trade Organisation in the Pacific — outlining how free trade challenges customary land practices at

The associated media points out:

Customary land is so central to life in the Pacific Islands that its importance cannot be overstated. Yet through the eyes of free trade agreements it is seen as a barrier to investment, something that needs to be challenged...

Previous attempts to privatise land in the Pacific have been meet with a strong refusal by Islanders. What we're seeing now is free trade advocates using these agreements to secure control over the usage of the land, which can in effect mean that custom decisions about land use are undermined...

We're seeing this in Vanuatu where its Trade in Services commitments at the World Trade Organization (WTO) mean the government's ability to specifically support and nurture land use for Indigenous enterprise, such as local bure owners or other tourist accommodation, can only happen if it gives the same support to foreign investors ...

The push for the Pacific Islands to become integrated into the global economy is a push to ask the Pacific to turn its back on the systems and cultural practices that have supported them for generations.

Progress in Political Economy

A vibrant new intellectual space is being created by scholarly activist friends and staff of the Department of Political Economy at the University of Sydney in New South Wales, Australia.

On 29 October this Progress in Political Economy (PPE) site published a post based on my non-market socialist approach to Thomas Piketty's Capital as expressed at The Historial Materialism Australasia Conference in Sydney:


Here's a post from a blog written by a friend who I met in the Blue Mountains (Australia) — though he has now moved further west in NSW and me south to Central Victoria:
I recently attended a methadone clinic for money addicts (in Australia this is called Centrelink, or the dole) that made sure I would have a two-weekly top-up of matrix-juice in my bank account. However, it wasn't until I travelled out of my normal bucolic surroundings toward the big city of Sydney (which I normally avoid) that I fully comprehended the grip of this methadone metronome that fully hypnotises its users. Sorry but I will not give horrible details of what happened to me in Sydney, but I will tell you I am much happier now than before, and I could write a book about what happened called, The Way I Changed in a Day. This drama is instructive, because it shows that empowerment of ourselves and fulfillment of our heart's desire is also possible (you should see the land I found thanks to Spaces of Love (FB group) -- but it is possible precisely without money.
In this post Robert takes a lateral or life's journey route through sustainability/economics issues. He and his family live very simply and have experimented with collective farming on borrowed land:


Recently a travelling Australian friend wrote a post simply headed, 'The final days of America'. It characterises a country governed not by people but by money. Here it is (without the extended complaint about American coffee!):
America is a land of beggars. There are the street beggars who approach every few meters rattling a tin under your nose. There are proportionally more of these than in Indian cities like Mumbai. Most, but not all, are black and many are mentally ill. There are also the mentally ill who are too psychotic for begging, yelling indecipherable rants or lurching into traffic. Then there are alcoholics who seek to start an argument over trivia they have dreamt up. Mental illness is more common in prisons than in mental hospitals but most common on the streets.
Then there are the ordinary everyday Americans reduced to  beggars. These are the waiting staff, shop assistants, bus drivers who supplement their pathetic pay by reminding you to show your appreciation with a tip. Every shop has a begging bowl placed strategically near the till, and every bus has a tip receiver, and woe betides any who fail to tip a waitress. Tipping became a factor during the 30s depression when people lived entirely from tips. Now it has become institutionalised as employers pay a pittance. President Obama is currently running a campaign, opposed by the Republicans, to increase the basic wage to $10 an hour. [In Australia the minimum wage is $18.70 per hour. Even adjusted for the difference in exchange rates, this makes Australia's basic wage at least 50 per cent more than Obama's ambit claim.] The argument is put that reducing wages will create employment, where already unemployment is chronic.

The point is that 50% of Americans live below the poverty line while the chosen 1–2 per cent live lives of extravagance. 

The American dream is so often quoted but the reality is a nightmare. Americans are so indoctrinated with their dream that all can be rich that they do not see the reality of their society. All government spending is seen as seen as bad unless it is the military. It shows itself in poorly maintained infrastructure such as roads and footpaths, many with long wide cracks making cycling all the more dangerous.

All Here in San Francisco pollution is chronic. The smog hangs around until about 10am every day and locals tell me that their window sills are covered with black grime every morning. There is always a haze as bad as Chinese cities. California sees the urgency and has instigated a clean energy program using solar and wind aiming to eliminate all fossil fuel generation.

Public space is shabby and neglected. Public utilities are relics of former glories. But most Americans dare not question the vast military expenditure because, after all, they are the great society, and all others are jealous of their success.

9/11 could have been a wake up call for Americans, arousing them from their dream state. Instead they refused to awake, yielding to the nightmare of warfare in Iraq and Afghanistan. Killing is so much easier than facing the reality of yourself.

Americans are not happy or friendly. They are geared to a competitive existence where they loudly assert their own rights. They are impatient and speak quickly in short sharp slogans. "You have a good day, now," becomes annoyingly familiar because of its insincerity. Even when a waiter spends time for a chat one suspects he's after a bigger tip. They often have trouble understanding me, and I often have to ask them to repeat before I can translate their rote learned rushed patter. When I tell them I don't want the milk in my coffee to be hot, they invariably reply, "So you want your milk to be really hot?"

And this is the society Tony Abbott [Australia's PM] wants to turn us into!!!

Capitalism Nature Socialism

The most recent issue of Capitalism Nature Socialism has a tribute to co-editor of Life Without Money, Frans Timmerman, who also co-authored the introductory and final chapters. Frans died earlier this year after a fifteen month struggle with motor neurone disease. It's available to download free here: